Showing posts with label belief. Show all posts
Showing posts with label belief. Show all posts

Tuesday, 21 June 2011

Falling away

The Sunday before last I didn't go to church. Not an unusual event particularly - I miss one or two every now and then when I'm out of town or busy or ill or whatever, and I had been every Sunday for many weeks previously and went again the next week.

But this was the first Sunday I missed when I could have gone, when I failed to attend for no reason at all. It wasn't an active decision just a lethargy, an unwillingness that sapped my self discipline and my energy. Of course, waking up and getting out of bed on a Sunday morning never comes easily but this time it was even worse than usual.

So why did it happen? Sadly I can think of one reason, that a few days earlier I had had some good news, winning a competitive scholarship, and, flushed with my own achievement, success and self reliance, I simply didn't see space for religion in my life. I was thankful, grateful and still intellectually curious about church but empty of that appreciation for God which should be part and parcel of our daily life.

Today I read an interview with actor Tom Hollander (who plays a vicar in a BBC sitcom called 'Rev') who said he was surprised at how many vicars go through agnostic periods, that theirs is a true 'relationship' with God. I feel a bit ashamed of how I felt last weekend but I also know that it comes as part of trying to live religiously and failing.

Saturday, 5 February 2011

Are religions evil?

What do all these have in common: a documentary on the BBC about illegal Zionist settlers in Palestine, the recent news about a couple owning a B&B who refused to accommodate a married gay couple and the heart breaking story of a little girl caned to death for being pursued by an older neighbour?

They all make me feel distinctly depressed about the extremes of behaviour that religious faith can drive individuals to.

This was also one of the points that kept being made repetitively, and boringly, in the debate between Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens in Canada. The former cited the many examples of extraordinary charity, support and goodwill carried out by religious people and groups around the world. The latter noted the evil, intolerant and bigoted behaviour often seen by the same.

So is it a one-all draw? Well, essentially, yes. Human beings have the capacity for exceptional love and kindness; and evil and misery. Religion, for its enormity, for its calls for sacrifice and powerful action, can push these tendencies to each extreme.

What distinguishes religion from other drives which lead people to behave well or badly (sexual desire, hunger, ignorance, empathy, etc) is that those extremists on either side are willing to act <<in the name of their religion>> The Israel/Palestine conflicts might be best understood using a realist theory of international relations but it is carried out in the name of God or, rather, of different Gods. Whatever the role of Judaism or Islam is in the conflict, it is tarnished by the religious language used on either side.

I think it is probably an important caveat that the vast majority of religions, in the vast majority of their interpretations, stress love, forgiveness, mercy and generosity. Those who commit extreme acts of viciousness are generally to be found far outside the majority opinion of the faith. This is not to say that there are no 'mainstream' popular theologians, thinkers and religious leaders who freely propagate some horrible beliefs - homophobia springs to mind here in particular - but these examples are rarely typical of the core teachings of the faith.

Friday, 4 February 2011

The God Gene, part II

It's Christian Union week next week and the faculty is filled with undergraduates in bright blue hoodies with 'Truth' emblazoned across the front and a line up off implausibly ambitious talks on the back. It's reminiscent of a tour hoodie for a rock band but without the flavour of dark and dingy suburban gigs.

In the student newspaper this week is a letter by the President of the CU in response to an article run last week about a genetic tendency to religious faith. He argues that religious faith is simply one form of the faith that everyone has - in relatives, friends, and so on. It is not some sort of speculative, general philosophical thought or 'worldview'. Specifically, he writes, Christians put faith into Jesus Christ, a specific person like mum, dad or Bob.

This might make Christianity sound like a pretty enormous leap into the dark - who would put their entire repository of religious faith in an individual they, nor anyone they knew, had never met and whose person is unknowable - but he does make an important distinction between religion as <<I think there's something else out there>> and as <<here are the people and creeds I trust in>>

Religious faith can be stimulated by trust in many more people and things than God - in other religious people, in institutions, in books, in prayers, in liturgy, in art, in music, in architecture, in experiences, in religious history, even in the natural world. Faith in one particular divine person can be a culmination of faith in every part of our experience, things that show God in a way that is far more accessible than one messianic figure.

Tuesday, 1 February 2011

The Hereafter

How to believe in the afterlife?

N says that it must exist - that there is <<too much love in the world for this to be everything.>> But I don't feel enough tension between these two forces - love and death - for this to be problematic. Couldn't there be too much love in the world for there to be more than 'this'? Or conversely, couldn't there be too much pain and suffering in the world for there to be an afterlife?

I have a different suggestion: in our world time is sequential (apart from, perhaps, at sub-atomic level or as we approach the speed of light). We live in chronos-time, where an afterlife must follow this life with death acting as the crucial marker in time separating the two. The afterlife is something else, somewhere else, belonging to the next period of time after the one in which our bodies are alive.

Time is subjective of course - it goes slower in a boring class, faster in a film, it stops in car crashes. Perhaps chronos time is one of the filters we use to turn noumena into phenomena. Noumenal time could be very, very different.

Ancient mythology included other kinds of time - particularly kairos, an undetermined period during which particular, peculiar or special events occur. Even as our lives are replaced, sequentially, by death, they could continue to exist in undetectable kinds of time. Perhaps to a time-less being - God - we are always alive, all events happening together, non-sequentially, although the concept expressed by 'together' relies on an idea of chronos time which is meaningless to God.

The afterlife has, occasionally, become an obsession within Christianity, generating theological contortions such as purgatory, limbo and chantries. We hear regularly of the virgins promised, apparently, to posthumous Islamic suicide bombers in the hereafter. If we are going to think about the hereafter at all our starting point should be the 'everlasting life' rather than 'afterlife', what does it mean to live forever? Is it like moving house into a new kind of 'existence' so that death never really takes place? Or is it the 'forever' part we should focus on - what happens to time when something lasts forever?

Monday, 31 January 2011

The God Gene

I'm interested by the arguement that there exists a 'God Instinct', which tilts those with the necessary genetic make up to be more inclined to believe that God exists (or something along those lines).

My first thought was that this is slightly embarrassing for religion - making it ultimately a matter of biology not revelation. If you believe because you were always going to believe and not because you chose to take a leap of faith isn't that reductive, even embarrassing, for those who hold that God freely gave them religion? It has nothing, ultimately, to do with truth. Or even 'Truth', if you prefer.

Then I read this article by Nick Spencer, a director at Theos. He argues that the God gene could work in a totally different argument - that it is suggestively consistant with a divinely created universe. Evolutionary advantage could suggest that:
Not only does God tilt creation towards life, and life towards sentience, and sentience towards intelligence, and intelligence towards morality and wonder, but he tilts that package of intelligence, morality and wonder that we call human nature towards himself. Creation delivers us to God's doorstep and bids us only knock at his door.
Of course it doesn't prove anything - transferring from helpfulness or inevitability to truth or goodness jumps Hume's is-ought gap - but perhaps it's less of a problem than I thought.

Spencer concludes saying its bad news for the atheist who must defend his/her beliefs for their 'unnaturalness'. I'm not sure he's right, there seems something rather noble about being unnatural, and this is where I worry that the God gener might still be bad for religion.

If religion were weird or 'unnatural' it would give religious faith a valourous, against the odds sense of overcoming an 'animal' disposition. What greater obstacle to overcome than genetic disbelief? Bigger than martyrdom or persecution. And what is the effect on personal experience - for the fool that saith in his heart there is no God, but trusts in him anyway?

The most reasonable answer is probably that of Michael Argyle, as quoted by Spencer:

psychological research can tell us nothing about the truth, validity or usefulness of religious phenomena: these are questions which must be settled in other ways
He is, however, only repeating the conclusions made eloquently by William James in Lecture I of The Varieties of Religious Experience. The 'nervous' causes of any belief do not determine our judgement of it, which is based rather on other values (how pleasing it is, how well it fits with other beliefs, etc). As the mad genius is no less a genius for being mad so the mad believer is no less true or insightful for his madness.

Saturday, 29 January 2011

Picking and Choosing - the Episcopal Church, Part II

Theo Hobson replied to my post below and said this:

<<I wrote about a visit to a Quaker meeting in the summer for this site. I said they throw out the baby Jesus with the bathwater of dogmatism.
Christianity is, at root, a cult of this mythic personality.>>

I replied with this:

<<A note - Quakers are not a Christian denomination, they are a group of believers who hold in common an approach to religion that cherishes different sources of truth and believes in the importance of personal revelation. They don't necessarily worship the 'mythic personality' of Christ, but they can do, if that is the truth revealed to them.
If you want to have Christ-worship in common with all your fellow believers then I suppose Quakers are not for you, but if you want a radically liberal approach to religion, which I think you do, and are willing to believe in Christ when those around you may not, then it might be what you are looking for.
This is just a thought, otherwise I'm pleased that the Episcopal Church can give you something of what you are looking for although I suspect more of it was to be found in England than you say.>>

I searched out Theo's piece on the Quakers (Thursday 18 March 2010 13.00 GMT) where he writes of his disappointment with the lack of Christian symbolism and structure at a Meeting he went to.

Friday, 28 January 2011

Picking and Choosing - the Episcopal Church, Part I

Theo Hobson's article in the Guardian newspaper (Friday 28 January 2011 12.44 GMT) describes his postive experiences in the Episcopal Church after his frustration with the Church of England (C of E).

Here's my response:


I too have been very impressed by the Episcopal Church's bold, brave and liberal stance on so many important issues, but you do the C of E a disservice. The point about an established church is that it includes a wide variety of voices - some liberal, many less so - and what could be more liberal than that?

There are few denominations which are spread as evenly across race, class, age and gender divides (not that the C of E doesn't have a long way to go on some of these). The Episcopal Church is a far more middle class institution than plenty of innercity C of E churches.

Joining in willingly with a bunch of people who have a load of different beliefs about many things but share a core trust in God is one of the most positive expressions of faith I can think of. Shopping around to find the church that agrees with everything you already think seems lazy and arrogant - challenge and diversity are essential in life as in faith.

Sure you don't get what you want in every way, but you do get to exercise skills of tolerance, argument and community. I'm not suggesting you should feel obliged to go to a mega evangelical homophobic stadium church if that is the antithesis of your belief, but then very, very few C of E churches are like that.

Holding onto liberal beliefs while actively engaging and changing the illiberal beliefs of others is a commission not a chore.

Lastly - one thought, why didn't you try the Quakers? Its not a ritualistic form of faith but there are meetings with clear purpose and format, its disestablished, and exceeds even the Episcopal Church in liberalism. An organised religion where members are called Friends and every book is treated as being as Holy as any other.